Why Do Traders Fail?

January 25, 2012

The following is an excerpt from Jeffrey Kennedy’s Trader’s Classroom Collection. Now through February 6, Elliott Wave International is offering a special 45-page Best Of Traders Classroom eBook, free.

I think that, as a general rule, traders fail 95% of the time, regardless of age, race, gender or nationality. The task at hand could be as simple as learning to ride a bike for the first time or as complex as mapping the human genome. Ultimate success in any enterprise requires that we accept failure along the way as a constant companion in our everyday lives.

I didn’t just pull this 95% figure from thin air either. I borrowed it from the work of the late, great Dr. W. Edward Deming, who is the father of Total Quality Management, commonly known as TQM. His story is quite interesting, and it actually has a lot to do with how to trade well.

Dr. Deming graduated with degrees in electrical engineering, mathematics and mathematical physics. Then, he began working with Walter A. Shewhart at Bell Telephone Laboratories, where he began applying statistical methods to industrial production and management. The result of his early work with Shewhart resulted in a seminal book, Statistical Method from the Viewpoint of Quality Control.

Since American industry spurned many of his ideas, Deming went to Japan shortly after World War II to help with early planning for the 1951 Japanese Census. Impressed by Deming’s expertise and his involvement in Japanese society, the Japanese Union of Scientists and Engineers invited him to play a key role in Japan’s reconstruction efforts. Deming’s work is largely responsible for why so many high quality consumer products come from Japan even to this day.

In turn, Japanese society holds Dr. W. Edward Deming in the highest regard. The Prime Minister of Japan recognized him on behalf of Emperor Hirohito in 1960. Even more telling, Deming’s portrait hangs in the lobby at Toyota headquarters to this day, and it’s actually larger than the picture of Toyota’s founder.

So why do people fail? According to Deming, it’s not because people don’t try hard enough or don’t want to succeed. People fail because they use inadequate systems. In other words, when traders fail, it’s primarily because they follow faulty trading systems – or that they follow no system at all.

So what is the right system to follow as a trader? To answer this question, I offer you what the trader who broke the all-time real-money profit record in the 1984 United States Trading Championship offered me. He told me that a successful trader needs five essentials:

1. A Method
You must have a method that is objectively definable. This method should be thought out to the extent that if someone asks how you make decisions to trade, you can quickly and easily explain. Possibly even more important, if the same question is asked again in six months, your answer will be the same. This is not to say that the method cannot be altered or improved; it must, however, be developed as a totality before implementing it.

2. The Discipline to Follow Your Method
‘Discipline to follow the method’ is so widely understood by true professionals that among them it almost sounds like a cliché. Nevertheless, it is such an important cliché that it cannot be ignored. Without discipline, you really have no method in the first place. And this is precisely why many consistently successful traders have military experience – the epitome of discipline.

3. Experience
It takes experience to succeed. Now, some people advocate “paper trading” as a learning tool. Paper trading is useful for testing methodologies, but it has no real value in learning about trading. In fact, it can be detrimental, because it imbues the novice with a false sense of security. “Knowing” that he has successfully paper-traded during the past six months, he believes that the next six months trading with real money will be no different. In fact, nothing could be farther from the truth. Why? Because the markets are not merely an intellectual exercise, they are an emotional one as well. Think about it, just because you are mechanically inclined and like to drive fast doesn’t mean you have the necessary skills to win the Daytona 500.

4. The Mental Fortitude to Accept that Losses Are Part of the Game
The biggest obstacle to successful trading is failing to recognize that losses are part of the game, and, further, that they must be accommodated. The perfect trading system that allows for only gains does not exist. Expecting, or even hoping for, perfection is a guarantee of failure. Trading is akin to batting in baseball. A player hitting .300 is good. A player hitting .400 is great. But even the great player fails to hit 60% of the time! Remember, you don’t have to be perfect to win in the markets. Practically speaking, this is why you also need an objective money management system.

5. The Mental Fortitude to Accept Huge Gains
To win the game, make sure that you understand why you’re in it. The big moves in markets come only once or twice a year. Those are the ones that will pay you for all the work, fear, sweat and aggravation of the previous 11 months or even 11 years. Don’t miss them for reasons other than those required by your objectively defined method. Don’t let yourself unconsciously define your normal range of profit and loss. If you do, when the big trade finally comes along, you will lack the self-esteem to take all it promises. By doing so, you abandon both method and discipline.

So who was the all-time real-money profit record holder who turned in a 444.4% return in a four-month period in 1984? Answer: Robert Prechter ... and throughout the contest he stuck to his preferred method of analysis, the Elliott Wave Theory.

Get 14 Critical Lessons Every Trader Should Know Learn about managing your emotions, developing your trading methodology, and the importance of discipline in your trading decisions in The Best of Trader's Classroom, a FREE 45-page eBook from Elliott Wave International. Since 1999, Jeffrey Kennedy has produced dozens of Trader's Classroom lessons exclusively for his subscribers. Now you can get "the best of the best" in these 14 lessons that offer the most critical information every trader should know. Find out why traders fail, the three phases of a trader's education, and how to make yourself a better trader with lessons on the Wave Principle, bar patterns, Fibonacci sequences, and more! Don't miss your chance to improve your trading. Download your FREE eBook today!

January 25, 2012 Why do Traders Fail?

December 20, 2011 How to Prepare for the Coming Crash

November 15, 2011 What are the Best Technical Indicators for Stock Market Trading?

October 20, 2011 Money, Credit and the Federal Reserve Bank

September 19, 2011 How Does Money Disappear in the Stock Market?

September 2, 2011 Behind Closed Doors at the Federal Reserve

August 18, 2011 Stock Market in Free Fall Territory

July 4, 2011 Can the Fed and the Economists Forecast the Future?

June 27, 2011 Trading and Investing Using Elliott Wave Theory

June 10, 2011 Is Lower Trade Deficit a Bullish Sign for the Stock Market?

May 3, 2011 Bin Laden and the Stock Market

April 19, 2011 Is deflation a threat despite Bernanke's printing press?

March 10, 2011 Pop culture, markets and the social mood

February 7, 2011 Should you or should you not diversify your investments?

January 6, 2011 Do Earnings Drive Stocks?

January 4, 2011 Is Your Bank Safe?

December 22, 2010 Why Diversification Does Not Work in Today's Markets

November 24, 2010 Individual Investors Have Jumped Into Another Fire - Muni Bonds Crashing

October 27, 2010 Why You Should Care About DOW (DJIA) Priced in Gold

September 23, 2010 Signs of Deflation

August 19, 2010 Efficient Market Hypothesis - Is the Market Really Efficient?

August 10, 2010 Economic Crisis That No One Saw Coming

July 12, 2010 Stock Market Bottom and DOW Dividend Yield History

July 2, 2010 Deflationary Crash Ahead - Long Bear Market Looming

June 9, 2010 How to Spot a Stock Market Top

April 19, 2010 Goldman Sachs Charged With Fraud

April 6, 2010 Understanding the FED

March 16, 2010 What To Do With Your Pension Plan?

March 15, 2010 Popular Culture and the Stock Market

March 11, 2010 Five Fatal Flaws of Trading

March 9, 2010 Does Gold Always Go Up In Recessions and Depressions?

February 25, 2010 Credit Default Swaps Indicate Trouble for European Debt

February 23, 2010 News is Not What Moves the Markets

February 22, 2010 What Chinese Malls Tell Us About the Economic Reality

February 20, 2010 How Elliott Wave Principle Can Improve Your Trading

February 19, 2010 Europe’s Return to Risky Investment

February 17, 2010 Stock Market Myths

February 11, 2010 Robert Prechter on Herding and Markets\’ “Irony and Paradox”

February 10, 2010 Will The Bears Relinquish Control?

February 5, 2010 EUR/USD: What moves forex markets?

January 27, 2010 Can Bernanke Survive the Bear Market?

December 4, 2009 If You Think the Past Decade Was Bad For Stocks, Wait Till You See This

November 20, 2009 The FDIC Anesthesia Is Wearing Off

November 6, 2009 Financial Mania: What record trading volume says about confidence

October 29, 2009 Black Monday: Ancient History or Imminent Future

October 20, 2009 Gold: Bull or Bubble?

October 9, 2009 Death of the US Dollar

October 5, 2009 Why Technical Analysis Beats Out Fundamental Analysis

September 17, 2009 Germany’s DAX: Free Insight into Europe’s Leading Economy

September 15, 2009 Five Tips for Successful Trades

September 8, 2009 How A Bear Can Be Bullish And Still Be Right

September 4, 2009 Prechter Stands Alone Again - He’s Done the Math

September 2, 2009 How IRAs Can Tie Investors’ Hands

August 20, 2009 The Bounce is Aging, But The Depression is Young

August 13, 2009 Emotional Pitfalls of Trading

July 23, 2009 The Three Phases of a Trader’s Education

July 15, 2009 Spot a Pattern That you Recognize

June 15, 2009 A Road Map To SENSEX 100,000

May 29, 2009 Gold Is Still Money

April 23, 2009 Think That Central Banks Move the Markets? Think Again

April 2, 2009 Bob Prechter on Silver & Gold

March 25, 2009 Key To Trading Success: Ignore Nature's Laws?

March 19, 2009 Are We Near a Low in the Stock Decline?

March 11, 2009 6 Questions You Should Be Asking About the Financial Crisis (And 6 Must-Read Answers)

March 6, 2009 How To Tell a Good Forecast from a Bad One

February 26, 2009 A Better Way To Handle a Shrinking Business

February 19, 2009 The Last Bastion Against Deflation: The Federal Government

February 10, 2009 10 Things You Should and Should Not Do During Deflation

February 6, 2009 Jaguar Inflation - A Layman’s Explanation of Government Intervention to Free Markets